Home > Corruption, Papua New Guinea > $44m fraud case: Accused trio can get case details

$44m fraud case: Accused trio can get case details

By K.C. Vijayan, The Straits Times

Three senior executives facing charges over a US$35 million ($44 million) fraud where they allegedly used a fictitious sub- contract will get to know who the deceived party claims to be, thanks to a test case ruling.

The trio will also get to know in their trial the reasons the document used is deemed fake, after the High Court overruled the Public Prosecutor’s objections to release of the details.

The test case, judgment grounds for which were issued on Monday, closely scrutinised the pre-trial information disclosure regime under the new 2010 Criminal Procedure Code.

Mr Stephen Li, Ms Lim Ai Wah and Mr Thomas Doehrman face six charges each, including a single charge of conspiring to issue an invoice in July 2010 which led to a US$3.6 million (S$4.5 million) payout.

They also face five other charges each of receiving proceeds of the payout under the Corruption, Drug Trafficking and Other Serious Crimes (Confiscation of Benefits) Act.

Mr Li was chief representative of China-based ZTE Corporation – a global telecommunications equipment and network solutions provider – for Brunei, New Guinea and the South Pacific Islands from 2010.

Ms Lim is a director of Questzone Offshore, allegedly set up to get commission payments from ZTE over a Papua New Guinea community college pro- ject. Mr Doehrman, her husband, assists the Papua New Guinea government under a trust for the college project.

ZTE was given a US$35 million deal for the 2010 project.

The trio allegedly conspired to have an invoice issued to ZTE, which falsely sought payment to Questzone as a sub-contractor in a fictitious sub-contract.

Prosecutors gave their lawyers a summary of the facts against them as part of the information bundle for the prosecution under the Criminal Case Disclosure Conference regime.

But lawyers Lok Vi Ming, Lai Yew Fai and Julian Tay, defending each of the three, said the summary was “silent as to the person or entity deceived”. It was also silent on how and why the sub-contract between ZTE and Questzone was fictitious.

Judge of Appeal Chao Hick Tin, overruling submissions by prosecutors Allan Loh and Dennis Tan, found a “factual gap which it needed to plug”.

He held that without the requested particulars, the trio would “be vulnerable to surprises at the trial” which the new disclosure regime was meant to prevent.

He said the prosecutors did not show there were “peculiarities or sensitivities which would be adversely affected” by the disclosures ordered.

But he rejected two of the defendants’ applications for further details as these relate to matters unlikely to have a substantial impact.

Justice Chao stayed the order last month pending the prosecution’s appeal to the apex court.

  1. feekay
    April 9, 2013 at 4:36 pm

    The PNG national involved in the College project with Mr Doehrman is Dominic Diya. I believe there were individuals in the former government that gave tacit support to the project because it seemed all genuine. The Jesuit order was going to manage and run the College and if it this is true, Jesuits have a good track record in the area of education and personal development and the College therefore had a very good chance of developing into another successful College and institution much like Divine Word and PAU. Somewhere in this story lies the truth or othyerwise. May be our elder and former diplomat, Dominic Diya, might shed some light on this. WE can’t simply create or raise suspicions as is often the case whenever PNGexposed selects a newstory like this to run without any investigative inquiry.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: